At RockPoint Law, lemon law is our core practice. Lancaster's down in southern Dallas County, right where I-35E, I-20 and I-45 come together around a whole district of warehouses and rail yards.
Three quick questions. No cost, no obligation.
Sending this does not create an attorney-client relationship. A case evaluation is a first step, not legal representation.
If your new car or truck keeps going back to the service lane with the same warranty fault, a complaint to the Texas Department of Motor Vehicles can end with the manufacturer buying it back or replacing it. And the hearing can be held by phone or video, which is a bigger deal than it sounds if you work shifts.
Our Texas attorney: Aaron K. Waldo, Texas Bar No. 24107954, licensed in Texas since 2018.
The rules that shape a Lancaster claim from the service lane to the final order, including how the hearing itself runs, with the section or TxDMV rule for each.
| Key figure | What it means | Where it comes from |
|---|---|---|
| 6 monthsto file | From the earliest of warranty expiry, 24 months or 24,000 miles after original delivery. Three interstates meet here, and the miles add up fast. | Sec. 2301.606(d) |
| Neglectis a defense | The manufacturer can plead abuse, neglect or unauthorized modification, so keep every service receipt next to the repair orders. | Sec. 2301.606(b) |
| Mediationcomes first | The parties must mediate before they can have a hearing. | Sec. 2301.703(c) |
| Phone or videohearings | A hearing may be held by telephone or videoconference, and with the examiner's written approval a case can be decided on written submissions alone. | 43 TAC Sec. 224.252 |
| No depositionsin the hearing | Depositions, interrogatories and requests for admission aren't allowed in a TxDMV lemon law hearing. | 43 TAC Sec. 224.252(a) |
| More likelythan not | You prove your case by a preponderance of the evidence. | 43 TAC Sec. 224.252(g) |
| Not boundby the order | Decline a final order and the proceeding is treated as concluded and the file is closed. | 43 TAC Sec. 224.266(b)-(c) |
| $10,000per day | A company that misses the order's deadline may face civil penalties of up to $10,000 per day per violation. | 43 TAC Sec. 224.266(j) |
Lancaster, Texas is covered by the Texas Lemon Law in Subchapter M of Chapter 2301 of the Occupations Code. A new vehicle may qualify when a warranty defect is still there after four repair attempts, or two if it is a serious safety hazard, or after a cumulative 30 days out of service for repair, with the attempts made inside the warranty or the first 24 months or 24,000 miles. You file with the Texas Department of Motor Vehicles for $35. If the case doesn't settle, a TxDMV hearings examiner decides it and can order a repurchase, a replacement or repair.
The statute starts at section 2301.601, and TxDMV applies it through its rules in 43 TAC chapter 224. Neither the City of Lancaster nor Dallas County has a rule of its own on top. For the whole statute, read our Texas lemon law guide.
Search results mix three of them. Lancaster, California is in Los Angeles County, and Lancaster, Pennsylvania is in Lancaster County. Each follows its own state's law, with its own repair counts and deadlines. What follows is Texas law, for the Lancaster on I-35E south of Dallas, a city wholly inside Dallas County. If your car was bought and registered in Pennsylvania, our Pennsylvania lemon law guide is the one to read. California drivers are under the Song-Beverly Consumer Warranty Act, which runs on different rules again.
Then the dates. Under section 2301.606(d), you have six months after the earliest of the express warranty expiring, 24 months from original delivery, or 24,000 miles. A week that takes in I-35E to Dallas, I-20 across to the west side and I-45 to the south adds up fast. The case begins when TxDMV receives the $35 fee (43 TAC section 224.232(e)(2)), so pay it with the complaint.
If Subchapter M doesn't fit your facts, the federal Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act may, and a court can award a consumer who finally prevails costs and attorney fees under 15 U.S.C. section 2310(d)(2).
Section 2301.605(a) gives three repair-history tests. Pass one and the law presumes the manufacturer had a reasonable number of attempts. The presumption is rebuttable, and each test only counts attempts made before the warranty expires or 24 months or 24,000 miles from original delivery, whichever is earlier.
Every card has a Lancaster example and a self-check to run against your own paperwork.
The same nonconformity is still there after being repaired four or more times by the manufacturer or one of its authorized agents or franchised dealers. It doesn't matter which franchised dealer for your brand did the work. If the fault goes quiet for a month and then returns, make sure the new order describes it in the same words, so the visits read as one defect.
A defect that creates a serious safety hazard qualifies after two repair attempts. Under section 2301.601(4) that means a life-threatening malfunction that substantially impedes your control of the vehicle, or creates a substantial risk of fire or explosion. Steering that stiffens without warning or a fuel smell with signs of a leak could fit. Use those words on the repair order when they fit.
A nonconformity that substantially impairs use or market value still exists, and the vehicle has been out of service for repair for a cumulative total of 30 or more days. The days need not be in a row. Under section 2301.605(c), days when the manufacturer or distributor lent you a comparable vehicle while a franchised dealer had yours are left out.
The repairs have to fall inside the warranty and the first 24 months or 24,000 miles. The six months to file then run from whichever of warranty expiry, 24 months or 24,000 miles comes first. Section 2301.605(b) stretches the days and miles for any period repairs were out of reach because of war, a strike, fire, flood or another natural disaster.
Passing a test shifts the argument; it doesn't end it. Section 2301.606(b) lets the manufacturer plead two defenses: that the defect comes from abuse, neglect or unauthorized modification, or that it does not substantially impair use or market value. The examiner orders a buyback or replacement only after finding those defenses don't apply (43 TAC section 224.260(a)(1)).
Your answer to the first is the maintenance receipts; for aftermarket parts, lifts and tuners, our Fort Worth lemon law page goes further. Your answer to the second is the repair order: one that says "customer states light on" undersells a car that shut down on the freeway. And under section 2301.603(b), the duty to repair outlasts the warranty for a defect you reported while it was in force.
Close to a test but not sure you're over the line? We go through the record at no charge.
This is a self-check against the statutory test, not legal advice, and it does not create an attorney-client relationship.
A Lancaster lemon law claim goes to a state agency, not a Dallas County courthouse. Under section 2301.607(a), the TxDMV process has to be finished before a refund or replacement is available any other way. The hearing itself can happen in person, by phone or by video.
The fee comes from section 2301.712. The complaint must be signed and give the delivery date, the mileage history and a copy of each repair order where possible (43 TAC section 224.232(b)).
Mediation is written into the statute: under section 2301.703(c), the parties must mediate before they can have a hearing. A TxDMV case advisor runs it by phone and in writing. Nothing binds you unless you sign a settlement.
When possible, an in-person hearing is held in the city where you live, and 43 TAC section 224.252 also allows a hearing by telephone or videoconference. The examiner can switch the hearing or the prehearing conference to phone or video on notice, and with written approval a case can be decided on written submissions. Hearings are set for four hours.
If you win, the examiner orders a comparable replacement or a repurchase less a use allowance, and accommodates your preference "to the extent possible." A vehicle that doesn't qualify for either can still get a repair order, and a complaint can be dismissed. The final order comes within 60 days after the hearing closes, by certified mail (43 TAC section 224.264(a)).
A complainant isn't bound by a final order (43 TAC section 224.266(b)). Accept it, and the manufacturer, plus the dealer to the extent the order assigns it a share, must act immediately while TxDMV monitors compliance. A company that misses the order's deadline may face civil penalties of up to $10,000 per day per violation. Decline it, and the file closes. Either side can move for rehearing, and after that section 2301.609 allows judicial review in a Travis County district court under the substantial evidence rule, working from the hearing record. Our Texas lemon law guide lists the rehearing deadlines.
All of Lancaster is in Dallas County. A separate warranty lawsuit, a Magnuson-Moss claim for example, belongs in a Dallas County court or in federal court, and federal court requires at least $50,000 in controversy. Those courts are set out on our Dallas lemon law page. While TxDMV has the lemon law claim, no court hears it. For the documents in order, see how to file a lemon law claim.
A Lancaster claim seldom needs a trip anywhere. TxDMV takes the complaint online, mediation runs by phone and letter, the prehearing conference is a call, and the hearing itself can be held by phone or video when the examiner allows it.
We collect the repair orders and service receipts, check the dates and mileage, send the notice to the manufacturer, file and pay the fee, and answer the case advisor. You can send us what you have from your phone.
Mediation comes first, and a lot of claims settle right there. If no final order has issued by the 151st day after filing, you may go to court instead, though a delay you cause stretches that date, so answer the case advisor quickly. If a hearing is held, the outside dates below run from the day it closes, and the decision whether to accept the order is yours.
The buyback remedy is for new vehicles, meaning never sold at retail before, whatever the mileage (section 2301.002(24)). You also need to be an owner under section 2301.601(2), which includes a retail buyer from a license holder, a lessee and a Texas resident who registered the vehicle here. After that, write down the delivery date, the warranty expiry, and the day the odometer passes (or is going to pass) 24,000 miles.
Really it comes down to two stacks of paper, and between them they answer most of what a manufacturer's going to argue. One's the repair orders, which show the attempts and the days out of service; the other's the maintenance receipts, which answer a claim of neglect. Keep both stacks in date order. And log each failure with the date, time and place, the way TxDMV suggests, plus if you can get a short phone video of the fault, that often says more than a page of notes would.
No refund or replacement can be ordered unless the manufacturer, converter or distributor received written notice of the defect and had an opportunity to cure it. You'll usually find the address in the owner's manual, under customer assistance. Send it certified mail and hang on to the receipt, because the complaint is going to ask you for the date the manufacturer first got written notice.
File online with the $35 fee paid at the same time; the case starts when TxDMV receives it. Mediation with a case advisor comes next, and section 2301.703(c) makes it a step both sides must take. Answer the advisor quickly, because a delay you cause extends the 150 days after which you could otherwise go to court (section 2301.607(c)).
If mediation fails, a hearing notice arrives and the examiner holds a prehearing call about the date, format, witnesses and exhibits. This call gives you the opportunity to request a phone or video hearing if it suits you better. The written final order follows within 60 days after the hearing closes. Then the choice is yours: accept the order and the manufacturer must carry it out, or decline it and the file closes.
What sinks Lancaster claims, more often than a weak defect does, is the small stuff. It's the oil change that nobody kept a receipt for, or the letter that went to the dealership's service manager and never got to the manufacturer, or an email from the case advisor that sat there unanswered for three weeks. Or it's a hearing date that ran smack into somebody's shift, when a phone hearing could have been requested on the prehearing call.
Plenty of owners file on their own, and TxDMV built the process so they can. No one can say ahead of time what an examiner will decide, us included. What we can do is close the gaps in the record, get the notice to the right company, and keep the dates straight.
When a manufacturer can't fix a qualifying defect after a reasonable number of attempts, Section 2301.604(a) has it repay your reasonable incidental costs and then either replace the vehicle with a comparable one or take it back and refund the full purchase price less a reasonable allowance for your use. You can say which you'd prefer, and the examiner is to accommodate that "to the extent possible."
Under section 2301.608(a), every order must name the person responsible for paying for the refund or replacement, and the manufacturer may not push onto a franchised dealer any cost the order doesn't assign to it. Read that line first. It tells you who you're dealing with once you accept.
The starting point is the total purchase price, leaving out interest, finance charges and insurance premiums. The $35 filing fee is added back, and a lender with a lien shares in the refund. The use allowance runs against a presumed useful life of 120,000 miles, split at the first time you reported the defect. A made-up example: a $39,000 SUV first written up for the defect at 7,500 miles, reaching a hearing at 19,500 miles.
It illustrates the formula; it doesn't value your case. Our Texas buyback calculator runs it on your own figures.
With a refund or replacement, 43 TAC section 224.262 repays reasonable, verifiable costs from losing the vehicle, such as alternate transportation and towing. If neither remedy fits, the examiner can still order repair work. A vehicle taken back under an order must be retitled in Texas, repaired, and resold with a disclosure statement, a department-approved label and a warranty of at least 12 months or 12,000 miles (43 TAC section 224.266(e)-(h); section 2301.610). Subchapter M has no clause that shifts your lawyer's fees; a court may award them on a winning Magnuson-Moss claim.
The purchase price without finance charges, less a use allowance split at the first report, with the fee added back
A comparable new vehicle from the same product line, same model year or newer
Warranty work the examiner can require when a buyback or replacement doesn't fit
Verifiable costs of losing the vehicle, such as tows and alternate transportation, paid with a refund or replacement
None under Subchapter M itself; TxDMV's cost rule covers them only if you hire a lawyer after being told the manufacturer has counsel, and a court may award them on a Magnuson-Moss win
Outcomes depend on the facts of each case, so no attorney can tell you in advance what yours will be.
Chevrolet
GMC
Buick
Cadillac
Chrysler
Dodge
Jeep
Ram
Fiat
Ford
Lincoln
Tesla
Rivian
Lucid
Acura
Alfa Romeo
Aston Martin
Audi
Bentley
BMW
Ferrari
Genesis
Honda
Hyundai
Infiniti
Jaguar
Kia
Lamborghini
Land Rover
Lexus
Maserati
Mazda
McLaren
Mercedes-Benz
Mini
Mitsubishi
Nissan
Polestar
Porsche
Rolls-Royce
Subaru
Toyota
VinFast
Volkswagen
VolvoTxDMV counts cars, trucks, vans and motorcycles as covered new vehicles, along with all-terrain vehicles, motor homes, towable RVs and neighborhood electric vehicles. A demonstrator never titled counts as new. Pick a type below and go from there.
If you bought or leased it new, it's covered. Doesn't matter if it's a driver-assist camera that keeps faulting, or the transmission slipping every time you climb up onto I-20, or a battery drain the dealer can't trace. All of it gets measured by the same three tests. See our practice areas.
Pickups and vans are covered under the same terms as cars. Now if yours is an upfitted truck or one of the heavy-duty diesels, our Fort Worth lemon law page explains converters and the powertrain rule, and our diesel emissions lemon law guide covers emissions faults.
They're covered, yep. TxDMV puts motorcycles on its list of new vehicles the law protects, and the four-repair, two-repair and 30-day tests apply to a bike unchanged. See our motorcycle lemon law guide.
Motor homes and towables, both covered. A towable doesn't have an odometer, so the mileage limits generally don't apply to it and its use allowance runs in days. See our RV and motorhome lemon law guide.
EVs are covered just like any other new vehicle is. A used one can't be bought back, but may have a no-fee, repair-only route under section 2301.204 while the original warranty runs. If you're buying used, look for the department-approved disclosure label a lemon buyback must carry, which no license holder may remove before the first retail buyer takes delivery. See our electric vehicle lemon law guide.
Real results from real clients who trusted
RockPoint Law with their lemon law claims.
I contacted RockPoint Law in July 2025 and by mid Jan 2026, I had received my settlement proceeds. A mid 5-figure loan was paid off and the manufacturer took possession of the vehicle. Not having that car payment and the mandatory full coverage freed up about $900/month. If you're on the fence about calling RockPoint Law, let it go. The relief you will feel when it all works out will be soooo worth it.
Read moreWas having nothing but issues with the DEF system in my Ram 3500. I didn't have high hopes because 3500 trucks are generally excluded from lemon law. The entire process from the time I contacted RockPoint Law to the time I received my settlement was under 6 months! Their response times were well above expectations.
Read moreMy Telluride's transmission would jerk so hard between gears that my coffee would spill. Dealer had it four times. When I called RockPoint Law, they asked the exact technical question I'd been researching for weeks. We got a buyback with reimbursement for my deductible and rental costs. They speak fluent mechanic before they speak lawyer.
Read moreTurbo failure on my EcoBoost F-150. Dealer replaced it once, then denied the second. Steven Nassi compared my case to known manufacturing defects for that engine. Other lawyers just saw 'engine trouble.' Steven built the argument around the known defect pattern. Secured a full refund.
Read moreOur minivan's sliding door would just stop working. Not a great feature with little kids. Tried to get it fixed under warranty three times. Final straw was when it almost closed on my son's arm. Leo was our attorney and got us a great outcome. They handled everything from start to finish.
Read moreMy family's cross-country road trip turned into a nightmare when our brand-new SUV broke down in three different states. Each dealership kept giving us the run-around. RockPoint Law tracked every failed repair, hotel receipt, and even our unused theme park tickets. They got us a full buyback plus $8,200 for the vacation that fell apart.
Read moreThe active suspension in my Ram 1500 started making a loud 'clunk' on every bump. Dealer replaced one part but the noise just moved to another corner. After the third repair, I was done. Natalie Nassi said, 'A repeated failure of a major chassis component is a clear impairment to value and use.' She didn't see a noise; she saw a failed system.
Read moreMy car is basically my mobile office. When the electrical system fried two laptops and killed my productivity, I reached out to RockPoint Law. Unlike the dealer who treated me as a nuisance, RockPoint Law saw how it impacted my ability to work. They secured a full refund on the vehicle plus $6,500 for lost income and equipment.
Read moreThe manufacturer told me I was out of luck. RockPoint Law told me otherwise — and proved it! Their lemon law experience turned my nightmare into a fair resolution. What impressed me most was their transparency — no false claims, just hard facts and harder work. Worth every penny and then some!
Read moreFrom the moment I walked into their office shaking with frustration, the team at RockPoint Law put me at ease. They listened patiently to my whole story, then laid out a clear game plan. Six weeks later, I was holding a check that made all those repair shop trips worth it. True professionals who deliver!
Read moreWe had two vans with the same transmission failure. RockPoint Law consolidated both claims, lined up build dates, and pushed for an extended coverage fix. Both vans were repaired, and we got downtime reimbursed.
Read moreThe hands-free liftgate on my SUV would randomly open in my garage, denting the door. I felt crazy complaining about a 'convenience feature.' Our attorney reframed it: 'An uncontrolled operation of a motorized component is a safety and property damage risk.' The team used my security camera footage as evidence. We got a solid settlement.
Read moreOur core practice is one type of case: defective vehicles. And because a Lancaster claim runs online and by phone, a client out in Wilmer or Red Oak gets the same attention as somebody a few blocks from our Dallas office.
The same attorneys who handle claims nationwide handle them here. Two minutes on who we are and how we work.
This part's a side-by-side. It's the same four moments in a claim, and the switch flips between doing it alone and doing it with us, so you can see what changes.
Under 43 TAC 224.252(f), a complaint may be dismissed if the complainant repeatedly fails to respond or communicate with the department. And look, after a long week of shifts, when a request comes in for one more document, it's easy to tell yourself you'll get to it later, and then later just keeps getting later.
If a party fails to appear, relief may be granted to the party that appears. A continuance needs good cause and a motion at least five days ahead, so if the clash with your shift only jumps out at you the night before, it's hard to fix by then, really.
Section 2301.606(b) lets the manufacturer plead neglect. Maybe you did every service right on schedule. If none of the paperwork got kept, though, you can end up arguing from memory against the manufacturer's records, and memory doesn't do great against a printout.
You aren't bound by the final order, and declining it closes the TxDMV file. Say you take a figure that leaves out the fee. Or say you turn down one that was fair all along. Either one's a decision that's hard to undo once it's made.
The letters from TxDMV come to us, not you. We answer them, and if something actually needs you, you hear about it from us.
Early on we let the examiner know what your schedule looks like, and we ask for phone or video wherever it makes sense to.
We reach out to the dealer, and to any quick-lube shop you used, and ask for copies of your past invoices. Those go in date order, right alongside the repair orders.
We redo the refund math ourselves from the contract, check who the order names as payer, and talk you through accepting or declining before any deadline runs.
The Census Bureau estimates Lancaster had 40,526 residents on July 1, 2025, every one of them in Dallas County. The city's economic development office points to three interstates, I-35E, I-20 and I-45, plus Loop 9, and a rail link to Union Pacific's Dallas Intermodal Terminal. Dallas College has its Cedar Valley Campus here, too.
A lot of that ground is part of the International Inland Port of Dallas, a logistics district its own site puts at more than 76,000 acres across five municipalities. Dallas County backs it through a local government corporation set up to market and develop the area. And according to the port's site, Walmart opened a 730,000-square-foot perishable distribution center in Lancaster, which makes it the company's second facility in the city. So if you're on shifts at one of those warehouses, the hearing format's going to matter to you, and the prehearing call is the time to ask for phone or video.
The franchised new-car dealers sit next door in DeSoto, out on the I-35E frontage road. A repair at any franchised dealer for your brand counts toward the tests, so if you had it in there once and then at another one up in Dallas, that's all the same record. Whichever service desk it is, ask for a printed order with the mileage on it, and hang on to the dealer's invoices for scheduled maintenance too.
We take claims from Lancaster and from the cities around it, like:
We don't have an office in Lancaster, to be upfront about it. Our Texas office is at 325 N Saint Paul St., Suite 3100, in downtown Dallas, and Lancaster clients seldom need to go up there. The fastest way to get started is the online intake form. We review every request that comes in and respond as soon as we can. You can also call (516) 550-3323. And if you'd like to sit down face to face, just ask and we'll set a time.
Quick word on these numbers before you read them. They come out of our firm's published lemon law settlement record, across brands, so they're firmwide results, and they aren't Lancaster or Dallas County outcomes. What they do show is what a well-documented defect claim can be worth when it's handled properly, which is the reason they're on the page at all.
Recovery on a vehicle with engine, electrical and suspension defects.
Recovery on a Macan with suspension, drivetrain, electrical and HVAC problems.
Recovery after electrical, engine and suspension failures on an electric pickup.
Figures are drawn from our firm's published settlement record and are not specific to Lancaster or Dallas County matters. Prior results do not guarantee or predict a similar outcome in any future case. See more RockPoint Law settlements
I had a really good experience with RockPoint Law. The whole process was a lot easier than I expected and everyone I dealt with was helpful and responsive. Whenever I had a question, I was able to get an answer without feeling like I was chasing anyone down. They handled everything and kept me updated along the way. Definitely glad I reached out to them.
Saw RockPoint Law and wasn't sure. Called anyway because I was at my wit's end. Natalie Nassi answered and she remembered me from somewhere else. Same calm voice, same no-nonsense approach. She took my case and handled everything. Manufacturer bought the car back. Name on the door changed but Natalie didn't. That's what matters to me.
Saw RockPoint Law online and wasn't sure because I hadn't heard of them. But I was desperate. My car had been in and out of the shop for months. Called them up and the person I spoke with was so easy to talk to. No legal mumbo jumbo, just straight talk. They took my case and got me a buyback. New name but they know what they're doing. Would recommend.
Honestly wasn't sure about RockPoint Law since I hadn't heard of them before. But I was desperate. My car had been in the shop five times for the same problem and nobody could figure it out. Service advisor started avoiding my calls. I found RockPoint online, called, and the person I talked to was really down to earth. They took my repair orders and handled the whole thing. A few months later, the manufacturer bought the car back. New name but they got it done. Would use them again in a heartbeat.
Saw RockPoint Law pop up when I was googling lemon law help. Wasn't sure about the name but figured I'd give it a shot. My Jeep Gladiator had a death wobble at highway speeds—front end would shake violently. Dealer replaced the steering stabilizer twice, still shook. The person I talked to at RockPoint was super calm and explained everything clearly. They handled the claim and Jeep bought the truck back. Glad I didn't let the new name scare me off. They got the job done.
Three details about the vehicle, and how to reach you.
No cost, no obligation. Contacting RockPoint Law does not create an attorney-client relationship.
A dedicated team that stands with you through every step of your Lemon Law claim.
Questions Lancaster drivers raise before filing, with answers drawn from the statute, the TxDMV rules and the department's own guidance.
Texas law applies, with nothing added by the city or Dallas County. Check which Lancaster you mean: California and Pennsylvania each have their own statutes.
Texas law applies, and neither the City of Lancaster nor Dallas County adds a rule of its own. The claim runs under Subchapter M of Chapter 2301 of the Texas Occupations Code, sections 2301.601 to 2301.613, and the Texas Department of Motor Vehicles hears it under the rules in 43 TAC chapter 224. Check which Lancaster you mean before relying on anything you read. Lancaster, California and Lancaster, Pennsylvania each fall under their own state statute, with different repair counts, deadlines and forums. This answer is for Lancaster, Texas, the city on I-35E south of Dallas that lies entirely in Dallas County. A new vehicle there can qualify after four repairs of the same defect, two for a serious safety hazard, or 30 cumulative days out of service for repair.
Six months from the earliest of warranty expiry, 24 months or 24,000 miles after delivery. The case starts when TxDMV receives the $35 fee, so pay it with the complaint.
Six months, counted from the earliest of three dates in section 2301.606(d): the day the express warranty expires, the day 24 months have passed since original delivery, or the day 24,000 miles have passed since original delivery. Which one comes first depends on your warranty booklet and your odometer, so look up both today. Lancaster sits where I-35E, I-20 and I-45 meet, and a driver who covers all three every week can reach 24,000 miles long before the second anniversary. File early. TxDMV's rule says a lemon law proceeding starts on the day the department receives the $35 fee, so a complaint sent without payment has not started anything yet. TxDMV's own advice is to file as soon as you see the dealer struggling to fix the problem.
It can. 43 TAC 224.252 allows a hearing by telephone or videoconference, and with written approval a case can be decided on written submissions alone.
It can. Under 43 TAC 224.252, TxDMV holds an in-person hearing in the city where the complainant lives when that is possible, and a hearing may also be conducted by telephone or videoconference. The hearings examiner can move a hearing or the prehearing conference to phone or video after giving the parties notice. With the examiner's written approval, a case can even be decided on written submissions alone. Each format has a trade-off. At an in-person hearing you may bring the vehicle so the manufacturer can inspect it and test drive it, and the rule ties that option to in-person hearings. If an early warehouse shift or a long commute makes a daytime hearing hard, raise the format on the prehearing call, when the examiner goes over the date, time and place.
An informal hearing before a TxDMV examiner. You prove your case more likely than not, both sides present evidence and cross-examine, and depositions aren't allowed.
A TxDMV hearings examiner runs it, and the rules call for an informal hearing. You carry the burden of proof by a preponderance of the evidence, which means showing your version is more likely true than not. Each side can present evidence and witnesses and cross-examine the other side's witnesses, under section 2301.708(c) and 43 TAC 224.250. Repair orders, warranty documents and the sales contract are the usual exhibits. Depositions, interrogatories and requests for admission are not allowed, so what you bring is most of what the examiner sees. The examiner may have an expert inspect the vehicle before the hearing, with notice to both sides. Hearings other than written submissions are recorded, and if a party fails to appear, relief may be granted to the party that does.
Two: abuse, neglect or unauthorized modification, or that the defect doesn't substantially impair use or market value. Keep every maintenance receipt.
Section 2301.606(b) gives the manufacturer, converter or distributor two affirmative defenses, and it has to plead and prove them. The first is that the defect results from abuse, neglect, or unauthorized modification or alteration of the vehicle. The second is that the defect does not substantially impair the vehicle's use or market value. Before ordering a buyback or replacement, the hearings examiner has to find that those defenses do not apply, under 43 TAC 224.260. A neglect argument would point to gaps in the maintenance history, so keep every oil change and scheduled service receipt, including work done at a quick-lube shop, in the same folder as your repair orders. If you added parts after purchase, tell your lawyer at the start, because the question is whether that change could have caused this defect.
No. You aren't bound by it. Accept it and the manufacturer must carry it out; decline it and the file closes. Either side can move for rehearing.
No. Under 43 TAC 224.266, a complainant is not bound by a final order. If you accept it, the manufacturer, distributor or converter, and the dealer to the extent of any share the order gives it, must immediately take the steps needed to carry it out, and TxDMV monitors compliance. If you do not accept it, the proceeding before the hearings examiner is treated as concluded and the complaint file is closed. Either side may also ask for a rehearing, and after that the manufacturer or you can seek judicial review in a Travis County district court under section 2301.609, where the court reviews the hearing record under the substantial evidence rule. Talk through the numbers in the order with a lawyer before you decide either way.
A replacement, a repurchase with a refund less a use allowance, a repair order, or dismissal. The order must also name who pays for a refund or replacement.
There are four possible outcomes. If the examiner finds the manufacturer could not fix a qualifying defect after a reasonable number of attempts, and its defenses do not apply, the order requires either a comparable replacement vehicle or a repurchase with a refund of the purchase price less a use allowance, as 43 TAC 224.260 sets out. The examiner is to accommodate your preference between those two to the extent possible. If the vehicle does not qualify for either, the examiner may order repair work or other steps to bring the manufacturer into line with its warranty. The fourth outcome is dismissal. Section 2301.608(a) also requires every order to name the person responsible for paying for a refund or replacement, so check that line when the order arrives.
A life-threatening malfunction that substantially impedes control of the vehicle, or a substantial risk of fire or explosion. It qualifies after two repairs instead of four.
Section 2301.601(4) defines it as a life-threatening malfunction or nonconformity that either substantially impedes a person's ability to control or operate the vehicle for ordinary use or intended purposes, or creates a substantial risk of fire or explosion. The label matters because it lowers the repair count. A defect that meets it qualifies after two repair attempts instead of four, as long as the attempts come before the warranty expires or 24 months or 24,000 miles from delivery, whichever is earlier. Steering that stiffens without warning, an engine that shuts off at highway speed on I-20, or a fuel smell with signs of a leak could fit. An intermittent radio or a squeaking panel would not. Describe the danger on every repair order in plain words.
Get the repair order anyway, with your complaint, the dates in and out and the mileage. A visit with no paperwork is much harder to count. Keep a log or video.
Ask for the repair order anyway. Subchapter M does not define a repair attempt in so many words, and whether a visit where the shop found nothing counts toward four is something the two sides can argue about. A visit with no paperwork is much harder to argue for. Make sure the order records your complaint as you described it, the date the vehicle went in, the date it came out and the odometer reading. TxDMV recommends a log recording the date, time and place of each failure, and a phone video of the fault helps too. If the fault shows up only on the drive home from a night shift, record it then. The examiner can also order an expert inspection when an expert opinion would help.
TxDMV monitors compliance, and a company that misses the deadline can face penalties of up to $10,000 per day per violation. Tell your lawyer and TxDMV promptly.
TxDMV monitors compliance with its final orders, and 43 TAC 224.266 says a manufacturer, distributor, converter or dealer that does not comply within the time set in the order may face formal action by the department, including civil penalties of up to $10,000 per day per violation. The same rule sets what happens to a repurchased or replaced vehicle. Before it is resold, it has to be retitled in Texas, carry a department-approved disclosure label in a conspicuous place and come with a disclosure statement. The defect that led to the buyback has to be repaired, and the next retail buyer gets a warranty of at least 12 months or 12,000 miles. If a deadline in your order passes with nothing done, tell your lawyer and TxDMV promptly.
Price without interest or finance charges, less full-rate miles to the first report and half-rate miles after, plus the $35 fee, with any lienholder paid its share.
TxDMV's rule starts from the total purchase price and leaves out interest, finance charges and insurance premiums. From that it subtracts an allowance for your use, based on a useful life the rule presumes to be 120,000 miles. Every mile before you first reported the defect is charged at the full rate, and every mile from that report to the hearing at half. Take a made-up $39,000 SUV first written up at 7,500 miles and heard at 19,500. The first 7,500 miles cost $2,437.50. The next 12,000 would cost $3,900 at the full rate, so half is $1,950. The deduction is $4,387.50, leaving $34,612.50, and the $35 filing fee is added back. Any lienholder is paid its share. That is arithmetic on invented figures, not an estimate.
No. The complaint, mediation and prehearing call happen online or by phone, and the hearing itself can be by phone or video. We can meet in person if you prefer.
No. There is no RockPoint Law office in Lancaster, and our Texas office is in downtown Dallas, about 13 miles north up I-35E. A Lancaster client seldom needs to go there. TxDMV takes the complaint online, the case advisor works by phone and in writing, and the prehearing conference is a call. We can take repair orders, maintenance receipts and the purchase contract by upload and go through them with you by phone or video at a time that fits around your work. The hearing is usually the only day that may need you in person, TxDMV sets its place, and the rules also allow a hearing by phone or video. If you would still like to meet face to face, tell us and we arrange a time that suits you.
Tell us the vehicle and what the dealer has already tried. No fee unless we recover for you.†
Same fault, back at the dealer again? Tell us what the vehicle does and how many times it has been in, and we'll compare that with the Texas tests and your six-month deadline. No cost†, no pressure, and no fee unless we recover for you.
Start My Free Case ReviewContacting RockPoint Law does not create an attorney-client relationship.
